Closing the discovery confidence gap: boosting brand reputation for AI discovery

Our Brand Discovery Index delves into the impact of new routes of discovery on senior marketers and their brands, revealing a discovery confidence gap. While marketers are confident their brands are visible where customers find them, many are struggling to be truly found, understood and chosen. Beth Nunnington, VP of PR, explores what the Index findings reveal about the growing importance of brand reputation in AI discovery. In this commentary, Beth gives her take on how US brands should be approaching their organic strategy in the changing discovery landscape.  

When brands lose control of their story


The Brand Discovery Index highlighted a disconnect in messaging across channels confuses both consumers and AI platforms.  I see this in practice when a brand’s website says one thing, the ads emphasize something else, and the coverage, reviews and expert commentary describe the brand in a third way. Keeping messaging consistent has always been the goal of good PR, but it matters far more now that LLMs build their understanding of brands from those sources all at once. 

When the signals line up, a machine can place a brand in the right category and surface it for the right queries. When they conflict, it guesses, often wrongly. For example, you might see an AI answer describing you as a budget option when your paid campaigns are selling premium, listing you in a category you’ve moved away from, or recommending you for a use case you don’t focus on anymore. Buyers feel the same confusion. They see your ad, search for reviews and find what reads like a different company. The fix is to tell one story everywhere, so people and machines reach the same conclusion about who you are and what you’re known for.

Reputation wins the final buying decision 


The US is a crowded market full of buyers who are used to comparing before they commit, and AI has made that comparison instant. In AI search your reputation precedes you. When someone asks ChatGPT or Google’s AI Mode which brand to choose, the answer pulls from your  entire digital footprint, from press coverage and expert commentary to reviews, Reddit threads and comparison articles. There’s nowhere to hide from bad reviews or a run of complaints, because the AI reads and summarizes it all for the buyer before they ever reach your website. If a competitor has stronger and more recent third-party proof, it wins, even when price and product are very similar. 

Our Index research found that 44% of US marketers engaged high-intent buyers, but lost them to a competitor. I’d put a large share of that down to reputation. Price and product get you considered, but reputation is usually the deciding factor when the options look similar, which in most US categories they do. The report quotes McKinsey research that shows Americans are more willing to abandon brand loyalty to find what they need, so US buyers are more open to switching at the last minute, and the brand with the stronger reputation is the one that benefits.

Why machines understand you, but don’t recommend you


Only 24% of the marketers we surveyed said inconsistent messaging was stopping people and machines from understanding their brand. That tells me most feel their story is clear enough, yet 38% say getting AI to recommend them is their biggest challenge. Being understood gets you into the right category, but AI still has to decide which brand in that category to put forward, and it makes that call from evidence: who is mentioned most often in credible sources, who experts quote, who appears in the best-of lists and comparison pieces it trusts. 

Plenty of brands are clearly understood by AI and still have very little  evidence behind them. A machine can know exactly what you are and still have five better-documented reasons to recommend someone else. Ahrefs found branded web mentions had the strongest correlation with appearing in AI Overviews, at 0.664, well ahead of traditional SEO signals. In the  Discovery System, being understood is the starting point. Being chosen depends on how much credible third-party proof sits behind you.

The importance of trust


Visibility gets measured from the brand’s side: we bought the media, we got the coverage, we rank for the term. Trust gets decided on the buyer’s side, and it depends on who is doing the talking. A spike of attention around a stunt or a big campaign can put a name in front of millions of people without giving any of them a reason to believe it’s the right choice. 

Our Index data shows it, with 61% of marketers reporting a significant drop-off between awareness and conversion. Earned media sits right in the middle of that. The best coverage gives buyers an independent voice saying this brand is credible for this specific need, from an outlet or expert they already trust. 

Coverage chased purely for reach is less impactful in the long run, as it often lacks relevance to the brand. The fact that 77% are seeing high media attention failing to lift demand suggests a lot of brands are chasing a spotlight that has little relevance with what they sell or what they want to be known for, so people notice them without a reason to buy.

The brand loyalty currency 


When people cut back, every purchase gets more scrutiny and switching feels like a risk. Third-party validation gives buyers the reassurance they need to take that step. By that I mean positive trust signals across a range of platforms, from credible sources that aren’t connected to the brand or paid by it. Which makes sense right, because owned content is always going to be self-serving and promotional. Earned content carries more weight because someone else is saying it, whether that’s a journalist in an editorial piece, a customer leaving a review or a stranger answering a question on a forum. A buyer thinking about leaving a brand they know will look for exactly that kind of third party validation. 

For a growing number of people, an AI answer is where that search starts, and it pulls from those same sources, from Reddit threads and Trustpilot scores to the press a brand has earned. Third-party validation matters just as much for keeping existing customers as it does for winning new ones. The brand with stronger independent proof has the advantage, because when money is tight nobody wants to take a chance on a company they can’t find anyone vouching for. In the US market, reputation is everything. But without credible third party trust signals, you’re just another abandoned brand, visible but not chosen.